
Today’s a rivalry game – the kind everyone’s talking about. You’ve had one of your best weeks of practice and can’t wait to show what you can do.
Your gear’s on, legs are bouncing, and adrenaline’s already kicking in.
Then the coach reads the starting lineup.
One name, then another, and another.
But never yours.
The noise fades and your stomach drops.
And before you can stop it, your mind fires off one line:
“I should be starting.”
It feels like fire and drive – but it’s actually a trap.
Because every time you say “should” or “shouldn’t,” you start playing by a rulebook that doesn’t exist.
The Invisible Rulebook
“Should” language tricks a lot of athletes because it sounds like high standards.
It feels like you’re pushing yourself, holding yourself accountable, staying hungry. In the short term, it can even work – you feel fired up, focused, in control.
But underneath, “should” is built on comparison.
It’s not the good kind of comparison – the one that pushes growth – it’s the one that quietly builds a gap between who you are and who you think you’re supposed to be.
Your body might be in the game, but your mind is somewhere else – comparing, calculating, correcting. And this is the opposite of being in the zone.
Because when most athletes describe being in the zone, they say things like:
“I wasn’t thinking”
“Everything felt automatic”
“I was just reacting”
The zone only exists when attention is 100% in the now.
Turn Frustration Into Action
Let’s go back to the player not starting in the rivalry game.
They’re on the bench, frustrated, replaying every drill in practice. Wondering what else they could’ve done.
That frustration makes sense because they care – but it’s also where most athletes get stuck because they treat it like a stop sign instead of a signal.
Frustration isn’t the problem – it’s just a message.
The key is to give it a job.
So instead of saying “I should be starting”, ask yourself:
“What can I do this week to make it impossible for the coach to overlook me?”
You can:
- Watch film on the player starting ahead of them and notice what the coach values.
- Ask the coach what one skill or habit would earn more trust.
- Set one measurable goal for practice (like winning 80% of puck battles).
- Review game clips to find why their last shifts were passed over.
Now your frustration has direction.
Turn Judgment Into Curiosity
Saying “shouldn’t” is just as harmful as saying “should”.
It sounds like accountability, like we’re owning our mistakes.
But it’s actually judgment. We argue with what already happened instead of learning from it.
Take a golfer who misses a short putt and mutters, “I shouldn’t have missed that.”
That thought doesn’t help them fix anything. It just keeps them stuck replaying the mistake.
But when they trade judgment for curiosity, everything changes.
They pause and ask,
“What actually caused that miss?”
Maybe their grip was too tight, their breath was too shallow, or they rushed their read.
Whatever the reason is – it turns the miss into feedback.
That’s the power of curiosity. It keeps you observing instead of overreacting.
Notice what happened, name what caused it, and adjust.
Play Without the Rulebook
Every “should” hides a comparison.
Every “shouldn’t” hides a rulebook no one agreed to.
Both pull you into a game of catch-up instead of growth.
When you drop that rulebook, you start playing free again.
Mistakes become data, pressure becomes energy, and frustration becomes fuel for improvement.
So the next time you catch a “should” sneaking in, treat it like a cue – not to judge, but to get curious.
That’s how you play free and own your game.
This blog was written by Coach Adam.



Blair has over 13 years of experience as a Professional Dancer, Assistant Dance Captain & Cast Manager, as well as an additional 17 years of training. Over the last 3 decades, she has lived and experienced first hand the highest of highs & lowest of lows that come with pursuing a career in the Performing Arts.




As a former member of McMaster University’s women’s soccer team, Emilie intimately understands the demands and challenges athletes face on and off the field. Although she encountered many challenges as a high-level athlete, particularly struggling with self-doubt and overthinking, Emilie was able to make a remarkable transformation when she began to embrace the principles of sports psychology.








Danielle Hanus, MA
Monica Russell, MA






