
Perfectionism can be a powerful force – if you know how to work with it.
Yes, it can lead to overthinking, fear of failure, and feelings of dissatisfaction—but it can also fuel success, drive improvement, and raise your standards.
It’s all about self-awareness and learning to regulate how healthy vs. unhealthy perfectionistic tendencies show up for you.
With the right approach, you can train perfectionism to work for you, not against you.
Here’s 3 strategies for you to take your desire for control and turn it into a competitive advantage.
Strategy 1: Control Your Process & Preparation
When things feel off – maybe it’s a rough game, a mistake you can’t shake, or pressure creeping in – perfectionistic athletes often try to grip tighter.
You want to fix it, control it, get it right.
But here’s the reality: you can’t control the outcome.
What you can control is your process. And your preparation.
If you crave structure or certainty, use that to your advantage. Preparation isn’t just a box to check—it’s a tool to create confidence and consistency. And when you prepare well, you give yourself the best shot to perform well.
Start by focusing on the controllables:
- Build a pre-performance routine that grounds you and helps you lock in.
- Create a reset routine to help you move on from mistakes quickly.
- Develop a personal scorecard to reflect on your mental state and your process to learn from your previous experiences.
The more you commit to your process, the less you’ll need to rely on a perfect result to feel in control.
Strategy 2: Control Your Expectations & Perspective
Controlling your process sets the foundation, but it’s equally important to redefine what success looks like.
Perfectionists tend to fixate on outcomes: wins, scores, stats, rankings, performance. But elite athletes stay grounded by focusing on the process—and recognizing that success comes in many forms.
How many times have you caught yourself labeling a performance as either “good” or “bad”?
Probably more than a few. That’s called ‘all-or-nothing’ thinking.
But the truth is, performance isn’t black and white—it spans a range of outcomes. As a perfectionist, you might set inflexibly high standards (which makes it hard to feel like your performance was “good”) or lean into excessive self-criticism (which pushes you to label it as “bad”).
Don’t fixate on one goal or limit what your success looks like.
Instead, challenge yourself to define a range of what success could look like.
Try using the Good, Better, Best framework:
- Good – What’s the baseline I can feel proud of or learn from?
- Better – What would feel like a solid, satisfying performance?
- Best – What outcome would exceed expectations and feel amazing?
This approach helps you chase excellence without demanding perfection every time.
And if you fall short of your “best”? That’s not failure—it’s feedback. Learn from it.
Use the Acceptance + Commitment (aka Jump in the Water) method:
- Accept what happened—without judgment.
- Commit to what you’ll focus on next.
This mindset keeps you from spiraling into self-criticism and helps you move forward with intention, ready to put in the work to grow and succeed.
Strategy 3: Control Your Response to Pressure & Adversity
After controlling your process and your perspective, the next step is controlling how you respond when the stakes are high or challenges hit.
Perfectionism doesn’t just bring high standards—it brings high emotions. And with high expectations comes a need for control. That’s why pressure can stir fear of failure, and adversity can trigger frustration.
Have you ever felt your emotions take over? Acted impulsively? Rushed to fix something right away?
As perfectionists, our drive to control the external often makes us more emotionally reactive. In moments of pressure (a high-stakes game) or adversity (team challenges), you might find yourself reacting strongly because you:
- Don’t like the situation
- Don’t want the situation
- Don’t understand the situation
If these show up often, it’s worth checking in with yourself. Trying to control the external leads to emotion-driven responses; controlling the internal leads to logic-driven ones.
Instead of reacting with emotion, respond with intention—through emotional regulation.
Try this 3-step strategy:
- Pause – Take a breath. Reset.
- Consider – What’s happening? What’s the context?
- Respond – How would my Best Self handle this?
Shift from emotion-driven to logic-driven by asking:
- Am I responding from emotion or logic?
- Is there real evidence I “failed,” or is that just the story I’m telling myself?
Managing your emotions doesn’t make you less competitive—it makes you more composed, consistent, and resilient under pressure.
Final Thoughts
Train your perfectionism to work for you, not against you.
Channel the healthy sides and manage the unhealthy sides of perfectionism through taking your desire for control and making it an advantage. It’s all about perspective and making things work for you.
Control what you can: your preparation, your perspective, and your response.
Let go of the need to be perfect and shift your perfectionism into a competitive advantage.
This blog was written by Coach Natasha.



Blair has over 13 years of experience as a Professional Dancer, Assistant Dance Captain & Cast Manager, as well as an additional 17 years of training. Over the last 3 decades, she has lived and experienced first hand the highest of highs & lowest of lows that come with pursuing a career in the Performing Arts.




As a former member of McMaster University’s women’s soccer team, Emilie intimately understands the demands and challenges athletes face on and off the field. Although she encountered many challenges as a high-level athlete, particularly struggling with self-doubt and overthinking, Emilie was able to make a remarkable transformation when she began to embrace the principles of sports psychology.








Danielle Hanus, MA
Monica Russell, MA






