
There’s an old story that perfectly captures the danger of overthinking.
A man is driving home late one night when his car breaks down on a rural road. He pulls over and realizes he’s got a flat tire. It’s an easy fix—if he had a jack.
He looks around and sees a farmhouse in the distance. So, he starts walking, thinking he’ll borrow a jack and be on his way.
But as he walks, his mind begins to spiral:
“What if they don’t have a jack?”
“What if they do, but don’t want to lend it?”
“What if they charge me? $20? $50? $1000?”
The longer he walks, the louder the thoughts get. By the time he reaches the porch, he’s convinced it’s going to end badly.
The door opens, and before the homeowner can say a word, he snaps:
“Forget it—I don’t need your jack.”
And he walks away still stuck on the side of the road, not because someone refused to help him, but because he let his thinking stop him from asking.
This story isn’t about a jack. It’s about what happens when we let assumptions and imagined problems take over reality.
The man never actually faced rejection—he only imagined it.
That’s the power of overthinking: it can make a situation feel hopeless long before you’ve even tried.
The Athlete’s Flat Tire
Athletes do this all the time.
Before a race, a workout, or a big goal, the mind starts building its own version of the farmhouse walk:
“What if I’m not ready?”
“What if my injury comes back?”
“What if I blow up?”
“What if people think I’m slower now?”
By the time they reach the start line—or even the training session—they’ve already imagined every possible way it could go wrong. They’ve pre-lived failure so vividly that confidence never has a chance to show up.
The result? They hesitate. They hold back. Or worse—they don’t even start.
In fact I learned this the hard way in the run up to my very first World Championships.
What to Do Instead
The goal isn’t to stop thinking—it’s to recognize when thinking turns unhelpful.
Here’s how I coach athletes through it:
- Notice the spiral.
When thoughts start looping through “what ifs,” pause. Name what’s happening instead of arguing with it. - Return to what’s real.
What do you actually know right now? What’s within your control? - Take a single action.
The moment you move—tie your shoes, start the warm-up, send the message—you shift from fear to focus.
Overthinking: Fear Disguised as Preparation
Overthinking often feels like being responsible, cautious, or realistic.
But it’s usually a form of self-protection fear dressed up as planning.
The mind convinces you it’s being helpful by rehearsing worst-case scenarios. In reality, it’s just keeping you safe from risk, uncertainty, and potential disappointment.
The problem is, those are the exact ingredients required for growth.
The Takeaway
The man in the story never fixed his tire—not because he couldn’t, but because he never asked for help.
He let imagined outcomes replace real effort.
As athletes and coaches, the same thing can happen when we overthink.
Overthinking doesn’t prepare you—it paralyzes you.
So the next time your mind starts spinning before a race or key session, remember:
Don’t talk yourself out of the moment.
Ask for the jack.
This blog was written by Coach Brant.



Blair has over 13 years of experience as a Professional Dancer, Assistant Dance Captain & Cast Manager, as well as an additional 17 years of training. Over the last 3 decades, she has lived and experienced first hand the highest of highs & lowest of lows that come with pursuing a career in the Performing Arts.




As a former member of McMaster University’s women’s soccer team, Emilie intimately understands the demands and challenges athletes face on and off the field. Although she encountered many challenges as a high-level athlete, particularly struggling with self-doubt and overthinking, Emilie was able to make a remarkable transformation when she began to embrace the principles of sports psychology.








Danielle Hanus, MA
Monica Russell, MA






