“Self-doubt is just who I am.”
That was Elisa’s belief for years (a goalie for TMU soccer) — it was a story she carried into every practice, every game, every mistake.
Physically, she could play. Technically, she was strong.
But mentally? She felt stuck in a loop she couldn’t escape.
Before we started working together, she genuinely believed that nerves, spirals, and anxiety were baked into her personality.
Not fixable.
Not trainable.
Not worth trying to change.
And then, after the first session her whole perspective shifted.
She left that first call with a feeling she didn’t expect:
“I actually grew today.”
For the first time, she saw her mental game not as a flaw — but as a missing piece.
For years, she assumed that feeling anxious, tight, or overwhelmed was just her reality. She thought she was “too stubborn,” “too negative,” or “too emotional.”
But the truth was simpler: she had never been taught the mental side of sport.
Never had tools.
Never learned how to interrupt spirals.
Never learned how to talk to herself in pressure moments.
She said it best:
“I didn’t think this was a real issue… I thought I was the issue.”
But once she started working on her mental skills — resetting, reframing, emotional awareness — she realized the problem wasn’t her. It was the system she didn’t yet have.
The difference between playing tense and playing free wasn’t talent. It was training her mind with the same seriousness she trained her body.
It wasn’t about changing who she was — it was about finally giving her mind the tools & skills it deserved.
The first step was about helping her cope with all the pressure she was feeling so she could get grounded and feel a sense of stability.
Strategy #1 – Finding Stability Under Pressure
As a goalkeeper, one mistake can hijack an entire game.
She used to spiral — fast. A bad goal. A coach yelling. A moment of panic. And suddenly, everything was shaking.
So we built a simple but powerful Reset Routine:
- Walk to the water bottle
- Spray water in the air & watch it fall
- One deep breath & release the moment
- Tap the gloves & lock in for the next action
It grounded her. It pulled her back to the present. And it gave her a reliable way to stay grounded and block out the noise.
“It instantly calms me,” she said. “It gets me back into my zone.”
This one strategy was key to her consistency.
Her willingness to engage in the ‘messy’ discussions of her emotions and have the openness to look at new perspectives ensured she made quick progress.
Through self-awareness and self-compassion she was able to understand her emotions so she could accept and let go of the distractions outside of her control.
Strategy #2 – Locking In Her ‘New’ Identity
When I introduced the Alter-Ego exercise, she almost rolled her eyes.
“Separate off-field me from on-field me? Really?”
But once she leaned in, something clicked.
She created Pazza Paolucci — her last name combined with pazza, Italian for “crazy.” A fierce, intense, unapologetically aggressive version of herself. The version that:
Attacks the ball.
Commands the box.
Plays with freedom, fire, and presence.
And when she put on her gloves, she started to feel it. It wasn’t pretending. It wasn’t fake confidence. It was stepping into the identity she needed to compete.
She had these traits and this confidence in her already. Clarifying them, putting a name to it, and then setting the routines to activate it. That’s what the Alter Ego strategy is all about.
And it worked.
The Results
The transformation wasn’t small.
Last season? She wasn’t even the starting keeper.
This season? Starting goalkeeper, team MVP, and nominated for Athlete of the Year.
But maybe the biggest change happened off the field.
She became more positive.
More patient.
More grateful.
More self-aware.
More confident in everyday life — not just in games.
In her words:
“I’m still my toughest critic, but now I do it in a healthy way.”
The Takeaway
Her journey proves a truth all athletes need to hear:
You are not the problem.
Overthinking and hesitating doesn’t mean you are flawed.
Having doubts and worries doesn’t mean there is something wrong with you.
Getting in your own head and underperforming — means you are human.
The worst thing you can do is start to identify as the problem. Instead, know that it is just a symptom that you haven’t trained your mind to cope with the adversities, pressures, and distractions.
What you are missing, just like Elisa was missing, is a personalized system so you can play free, perform under pressure, and unleash the most confident version of yourself.
This blog was written by Coach Cassidy.



Blair has over 13 years of experience as a Professional Dancer, Assistant Dance Captain & Cast Manager, as well as an additional 17 years of training. Over the last 3 decades, she has lived and experienced first hand the highest of highs & lowest of lows that come with pursuing a career in the Performing Arts.




As a former member of McMaster University’s women’s soccer team, Emilie intimately understands the demands and challenges athletes face on and off the field. Although she encountered many challenges as a high-level athlete, particularly struggling with self-doubt and overthinking, Emilie was able to make a remarkable transformation when she began to embrace the principles of sports psychology.








Danielle Hanus, MA
Monica Russell, MA






