
Negative thoughts aren’t the problem. Believing them is.
After a mistake or a tough game, your brain will tell you extreme things. That one miss means you “always” fail. That anything less than perfect is “complete failure”. That one error just ruined your entire season.
None of that is true. But in the moment, it all feels real.
The difference between spiraling and staying confident? Knowing how to spot these thinking traps and shut them down before they take over.
Here are the four most common traps – and exactly how to fight each one back.
#1 Always/Never Trap
Have you taken one bad moment and applied it to all future situations?
It sounds like: “I always miss that shot”
It feels like: You miss a goal and suddenly feel like you never score.
Strong emotions make it easy to lose perspective. One mistake can feel like a pattern, but that’s not the full truth.
Ways to challenge this thinking trap:
- Find exceptions: Challenge the thought logically: Is this really always happening or just sometimes?
- Be intentional with your language: Replace “always/ never” with phrases like: “that time… that drill… sometimes”
One bad moment – a missed shot, goal, or opportunity – doesn’t define you.
#2 All-or-Nothing Thinking
Have you viewed your performance as a total success or total failure, with no middle ground?
It sounds like: “If I don’t win gold, I’m a complete failure”
It feels like: You set a personal best but still see the performance as a failure.
We categorize results into black-and-white buckets: success or failure. Anything in between feels like ‘not enough’ and we lump it down to failure.
Strategy to work through it:
- Good/ Better/ Best: Define a range of success.
- Good: The baseline you can be proud of.
- Better: A solid, satisfying performance.
- Best: A performance that exceeds expectations.
Performance isn’t all-or-nothing. Defining a range of success keeps your perspective balanced and motivation high.
#3 Worse-Case Scenario
Have you found yourself giving one mistake far too much weight or importance?
It sounds like: “If I miss this, the whole season is ruined”
It feels like: One mistake snowballs into imagining disaster, like not making the team next year.
Our brains are wired to treat potential threats as urgent and we go into protective mode. Most ‘worst cases’ don’t happen, but the anxiety feels very real.
How to reframe it:
- Coping Planning: Ask yourself, What’s the actual likelihood this will happen? How can I handle it if it does?
- Zoom Out: One moment doesn’t define your whole performance.
- Pick one Goal: Focus on what you can control in the next moment.
To stop catastrophizing, limit the weight you give your mistakes and zoom out.
#4 Should’ve, Would’ve, Could’ve
Have you set impossible rules for yourself or taken all the blame after a loss?
It sounds like: “I should’ve played better and helped my team more”
It feels like: You feel like you must never make mistakes or always carry the team.
Our competitive side takes over. Instead of learning from the game, we dwell on perceived failures.
Ways to shift this thinking:
- Adjust Self-Talk: Replace “I should’ve…” with “Next time… My goal is to…”
- Practice Self-Compassion: Give yourself permission to be human. Acknowledge effort, leadership, communication and consistency – not just outcomes.
Transform self-criticism into instructive guidance. Learn from experiences, don’t dwell.
Your 3 Step Process
The next time you catch yourself in a thinking trap, don’t just try to push the thought away or hope it disappears. That doesn’t work. Instead, use this three-step process:
Name it.
Challenge it.
Replace it.
This isn’t about eliminating negative thoughts. They’re going to show up – that’s normal. This is about knowing which thoughts to trust and which ones to dismantle.
This blog was written by Coach Natasha.



Blair has over 13 years of experience as a Professional Dancer, Assistant Dance Captain & Cast Manager, as well as an additional 17 years of training. Over the last 3 decades, she has lived and experienced first hand the highest of highs & lowest of lows that come with pursuing a career in the Performing Arts.




As a former member of McMaster University’s women’s soccer team, Emilie intimately understands the demands and challenges athletes face on and off the field. Although she encountered many challenges as a high-level athlete, particularly struggling with self-doubt and overthinking, Emilie was able to make a remarkable transformation when she began to embrace the principles of sports psychology.








Danielle Hanus, MA
Monica Russell, MA






