
A dancer I work with recently came to me frustrated after a rehearsal. Her choreographer had given her some feedback about one of her turns. The feedback itself was straightforward; there was something she needed to work on. But somewhere between hearing the feedback and leaving the studio, my athlete’s brain added a little more to the story. She started thinking, I’m not good at turns. And from there, it was easy for her to go one step further. If I’m not good at turns, I’m going to struggle with them in competition.
Nothing about the original feedback had changed. But the meaning she had attached to it had. This happens to athletes all the time. We treat a mistake as “evidence” that we’re not good enough. A disappointing performance becomes proof that we’re getting worse. One difficult practice becomes a prediction about what will happen in competition or on game day.
In the space of a few seconds, our brains can move from what happened in the moment to what we believe it says about us to what we think is going to happen next. Learning to notice that shift can help us separate the facts from the story our brain is telling us. So let’s break it down.
Start With What You Know
Information is something you know or can observe.
I missed the shot. I finished slower than my goal time. I fell on my tumbling pass. My coach gave me feedback.
Information doesn’t tell you whether you’re good or bad at something. It simply describes what happened in the moment. And this is often where athletes can get themselves into trouble. Instead of staying with what they know, they immediately start assigning meaning to it.
I missed the shot becomes I’m terrible at this.
I finished slower than my goal time becomes I’m not fit enough.
I fell on my tumbling pass becomes I’m not good at this skill.
The information hasn’t changed. The story around it has.
When Information Becomes a Verdict
A verdict takes one piece of information and turns it into a judgment about you, your ability, or your potential. I missed the shot is information. I’m terrible at shooting is a verdict.
The problem isn’t that the verdict is always entirely untrue. You might genuinely have something to work on. You might not be where you want to be yet. The problem is that one piece of information rarely gives you enough evidence to make a sweeping judgment about yourself.
A missed shot can tell you that you missed a shot. It can’t tell you that you’re a bad player. A slower-than-expected race can tell you that you didn’t hit your goal time. It can’t tell you that you’re not fit enough or that you’re not capable of getting there.
When we turn information into a verdict, we stop looking at what happened and start judging ourselves based on what happened. And once we’ve decided what something says about us, it’s much easier for our brains to start predicting what will happen next.
When Verdict Turns Into a Prediction
Once we’ve decided what something means about us, it’s easy to start predicting what will happen next. A prediction takes what happened and turns it into a story about the future.
I struggled with this skill today becomes I’m going to struggle with it in competition.
I had a bad practice becomes I’m going to have a bad performance.
My coach gave me feedback becomes They’re going to lose confidence in me.
Now the brain has moved through three steps: what happened, what it means about me, and what I think will happen next. But none of those steps after the information are facts.
You might struggle with the skill again in competition. Your next performance might not go the way you want. Your coach might have concerns. But you don’t know any of those things yet. And that’s an important distinction. A prediction can feel certain without actually being certain.
Come Back to the Information
So the next time you notice your thoughts spiraling after a mistake, piece of feedback, or disappointing performance, pause and ask yourself: What do I actually know?
Maybe you know that you missed the shot. You know that your race was slower than you wanted. You know that your coach gave you feedback. You know that you struggled with a skill in practice. Start there.
You don’t need to convince yourself that everything is going to go perfectly, and you don’t need to pretend that the mistake doesn’t matter. You just need to separate what happened from the story you’re telling yourself and what you’re predicting will happen next.
This blog was written by Coach Elaina.



Blair has over 13 years of experience as a Professional Dancer, Assistant Dance Captain & Cast Manager, as well as an additional 17 years of training. Over the last 3 decades, she has lived and experienced first hand the highest of highs & lowest of lows that come with pursuing a career in the Performing Arts.




As a former member of McMaster University’s women’s soccer team, Emilie intimately understands the demands and challenges athletes face on and off the field. Although she encountered many challenges as a high-level athlete, particularly struggling with self-doubt and overthinking, Emilie was able to make a remarkable transformation when she began to embrace the principles of sports psychology.








Danielle Hanus, MA
Monica Russell, MA






